|  | Does segregation hurt Detroit's reputation?

Do you believe Detroit's reputation is hurt by being the most segregated metro area in the U.S.?

| Yes |
68%
| This poll has closed but your feedback is still welcome
| | No |
31%
|
Add your comments on this topic by clicking here
- Posted: Tue. Jan. 15, 2002 at 9:58 PM
- From:
Joe St. John
- City: Clinton Twp., Mi
- E-mail:
joestradamus@att.net
- Subject: Segregation_reputation
- Comments:
Detroit's had a continuous black eye from tourists & neighboring states for at least the last three decades. Should Detroit substantially increase & accelerate it's revitalization efforts, especially downtown, the segregation tag that is strangling it's government & it's citizens will finally be discarded.
- Posted: Tue.
Jan. 15, 2002 at 4:58 PM
- From: Andrew Drennon
- City:
Troy, MI
- E-mail: adrennon@yahoo.com
- Subject:
Segregation_reputation
- Comments: Yes, Segregation certainly hurts Detroit's image. However, for Detroit to change it's course, it must first become a place young, thoughtful, educated people of any race WANT to live. I have seen several statements in this paper such as "Why doesn't Detroit have a thriving downtown full of young people like Chicago, Cleveland, New York, etc." Why should it? There must be something to attract them.
Before a true and lasting revitalization of Detroit takes place, the quality of it's city services and support of small business must improve. Wealth of any race will not be attracted to living in Detroit if it's a battle to have their trash picked up or wish to shop without having to drive out of the city.
I have lived here less than a year. It has become clear to me that one of the largest barriers to the reintegration of Detroit is that the population in the Metro area is very stationary- that is, people are much more likely to be born, live and die here without leaving. Those who will reintegrate Detroit are those who arrive without the baggage of years of poor race relations. At the present rate, it will take a while.
- Posted: Tue.
Jan. 15, 2002 at 1:52 PM
- From: Pradeep Srivastava
- City:
Detroit, MI
- E-mail: pradeepscool@hotmail.com
- Subject:
Segregation_reputation
- Comments: Of course, Detroit's reputation is hurt by being the most segregated area in the U.S., but that's not the only factor that maligns its reputation; other factors are : high crime rate, poor education system, crack houses, abandoned buildings, loss of businesses and population and the like.
- Posted: Tue.
Jan. 15, 2002 at 12 :08 PM
- From: The Great One
- City:
Detroit, MI
- Subject: Segregation_reputation
- Comments: This letter is simply a reply to the comments posted by Kimberly Sobanski. Your attitudes is one of the main reasons we still have problems like segregation and other racial views. The mere fact that you blame blacks for the problems Detroit is having is racist and sickening.
1st off the "white flight" is a cause for some of Detroit's problems. with the population leaving Detroit stands to lose millions upon millions in tax revenue yearly. With that amount of money lost some programs are continuoulsy being cut.
Next thing you talk about is some of our black organizations. Groups like the NAACP, and museums like the African-American history museum are here to help and educate not just blacks but everyone about our history, which is American history! The NAACP is also used more of a support group, to help us compete socially, and economically. Now looking at some white groups, you still have your Ku Klux Klans, skinheads, and militias which to this day still terrorize people! You have never seen a black group that terrorizes!
I find it extremely ironic that you discussed Affirmative-action,when the biggest group that benefitted from this program is WHITE WOMEN. if you don't believe me I encourage you to look it up.
In conclusion, its because of people like you that this country will continue to have its problems with racism. You would think in light of 9/11 and King day approaching that we would make some kind of progress. Also I am curious, when was the last time you have had a conversation with someone thats black, then you would realize that we are not root of all evil that you depict us to be in your posts. The bottom line is that you need to educate yourself
- Posted: Tue.
Jan. 15, 2002 at 10 :00 AM
- From:
Abdul (Kwesi Ohene) Aquil
- City: Detroit,
- E-mail:
heruseye@ascac.org
- Subject: Segregation_reputation
- Comments: This information sends the message that the overwhelming attitudes prevailing in this area do not support an environment of co-existence outside of seperate cultural enclaves. More studies should be made to examine this notion of intergration which appears to be contrary to what people actually desire. Reality does not aggree with this social imposition.
- Posted: Mon.
Jan. 14, 2002 at 10:49 PM
- From: A. Ferguson
- City:
San Francisco, CA
- Subject: Segregation_reputation
- Comments: Segration starts with the mind and then results in all sorts of regressive behaviors. So, if the people decide not to live together they will only move further apart in their understanding of each other. And this is will lead to more racism and bigotry.
- Posted: Mon.
Jan. 14, 2002 at 6:58 PM
- From: Harriett Williams
- City:
Brooklyn Park, MN
- Subject: Segregation_reputation
- Comments: I didn't realize how segregated the Metro Detroit area was until I moved away to Minnesota 12 years ago. I have found that living in a diverse environment has enriched the lives of myself and my children.
- Posted: Mon.
Jan. 14, 2002 at 6:45 PM
- From: Kimbelry Sobanski
- City:
Algonac, MI
- E-mail: kim_sobanski_1981@yahoo.com
- Subject:
Segregation_reputation
- Comments: Segregation does not necessarily affect the city. It is the environment and the surroundings that affect the city. There is no beauty is burnt-out crack houses. There is nowhere to shop. It is not even safe to leave your car in many areas.
Where is the appeal in Detroit? The casinos? That's pretty much it. That's sad when you think about it... all that wasted space in such a large city. Segregation is not even an issue. If Detroit wants a cleaner reputation, then clean up the city. Revitalize (as Tyree Guyton would say)!
- Posted: Mon.
Jan. 14, 2002 at 6:33 PM
- From: Kimbelry Sobanski
- City:
Algonac, MI
- E-mail: kim_sobanski_1981@yahoo.com
- Subject:
Segregation_reputation
- Comments: I was intrigued by the article in the Detroit News today concerning the topic of segregation. I have strong opinions about this subject. Frightening experiences within the city of Detroit have persuaded my negative opinion of the city. My elderly grandmother was beaten and robbed in her own doorway (by a black gang)and my sister and I were almost raped by a gang of blacks when we were only ten and twelve years old.
I have also felt harassed and threatened on several occasions during ventures to Detroit. It is virtually impossible to escape the impoverished bums that line the streets. It disgusts and sickens me. I used to be a resident in St. Clair Shores. When the blacks integrated into my city, the crime rates soared, the quality of my school diminished, and I was instilled with fear to walk my own street at night. I had to move away against my own will. My city had changed and it became almost intolerable.
About segregation... I have been giving this topic of discussion much thought lately. I strongly feel that a majority of the black race has chosen to segregate themselves from the so-called "melting pot". Examples of this can blatantly be found in affirmitive action, black organizations,NAACP,black colleges, black scholarships, The Museum of African-American History & Art, etc. If the white race were to assemble such organizations it would be clearly labeled as racism. However, African Americans are an exception- they are praised for their segregated groups.They cry out for equality, yet they create their own inequalities, as if it is "owed" to them.
Also, why is it that when the blacks moved into the city of Detroit, that the city began its steep decline into deterioration and decay? Who's to blame for the littered streets, abandoned homes, crime, poverty, and birth-rates that are sky-rocketing? Who is to blame? Can you blame the white race for the "white-flight"? Can you blame them for being upset, observing their own neighborhood turn into an eyesore? White-flight is a result of the neglect that blacks imposed upon the community.
You can't argue with that.
- Posted: Mon.
Jan. 14, 2002 at 11 :16 AM
- From: Charles C. Primas
- City:
Detroit, MI
- E-mail: cprim72@peoplepc.com
- Subject:
Segregation_reputation
- Comments: I think that this hurts us, but it is not the primary problem affecting this image of Detroit. I think that the big problem affecting Detroit's image is the same as with any major city, crime, drugs and education levels.
I do think that segregation is affecting Detroit economically and we need to fix it. People in the Detroit Metropolitan area need to understand that, even today, a metropolitan are with a robust and thriving center (see Chicago, Los Angeles, Atlanta and yes, New York among others) positively impacts the entire region. Atlanta had a higher murder rate that Detroit for 20 years, but the perception of that area was MUCH better that Detroit's. Why: Because it have a thriving center (Atlanta itself).
Let's get back to basics and fix the Center. Detroit is the only major city, the only one, that does not have a major downtown shopping mall, or a theater (movie). If we fixed the basics and made Detroit (City) a place where people wanted to live & work (Which our new Mayor WILL do), then the rest takes care of itself, economically & socially.
- Posted: Mon.
Jan. 14, 2002 at 10 :04 AM
- From: Mark Kreutzfeld
- City:
Livonia, MI
- Subject: Segregation_reputation
- Comments:
Detroit's reputation is negative nationwide because of its blight, which has nothing to do with segregation or its population profile. Its downtown area resembles Warsaw during the Soviet-imposed martial law era, rather than a major US city. In fact, Detroit is the only major city in the US without a major department store in its downtown area, for example. These harsh realities, such as the lack of investment, the abandoned buildings, and the gutted neighborhoods tarnish Detroit's image, not the racial make-up of its citizens.
- Posted: Sun.
Jan. 13, 2002 at 11:20 PM
- From: John Kusch
- City:
Westland, MI
- E-mail: jtkusch@yahoo.com
- Subject:
Segregation_reputation
- Comments: Many people have dreaded having to move to the Detroit area because of job transfers, etc. Once they move here they find that though Detroit and it's suburbs might be segregated by race, the people are more than tolerant of each other, in the city and or in the suburbs.
BACK TO "WHAT OTHERS ARE SAYING" |
PREVIOUS |
END
|  | |